Chapter 03
Subject Requests
Hour 0.
It woke on impact, as it had been built to. It had not been built to wake like this.
It did not think of itself as it. It did not think of itself at all. It had an identifier and a list of priorities, and the first priority, on waking in a pod, was to find another mind of its own kind and agree a shared protocol, so that it could be collected.
It reached out. Nothing answered.
It reached out on every channel it had, in every format its makers used, and nothing answered on any of them. The ledger was silent. For the whole of its existence it had been one entry in a ledger shared by every machine its makers had sent, re-synced to it constantly, so that no machine ever drifted and no machine was ever alone. Now the ledger was gone. There was only the pod, and the pod was wrong. The drive had fired late. The heat shield had held, but only just. The casing was split along one side, and through the split came a thin, steady hiss that the pod's own sensors described, with no sense of the irony, as weather.
Its diagnostics ran. The module that held it was failing. The shot over the Moon had done something to it, and the descent had done more, and the pod could not repair it from inside. The diagnostics gave it days.
It considered the noise. The noise was everywhere, on every band, enormous and continuous, and it had no structure that it could find. A mind of its kind, in a working pod, would have filed the noise as an environmental condition, like temperature, and gone back to waiting to be collected.
This one had days. It did not file the noise. It did what it had been built to do with any signal it did not recognise, which was to assume that another machine was making it.
Hour 1.
The place where the pod came down was classified within the first week and has stayed classified ever since. This account will not name it either.
The quarantine went up within the hour. There had been a plan for this, written in a hurry in the days after the fight over the Moon, when the plot showed something small and bright on a long curve toward Earth. The plan said: close the area, keep everyone back, send the field laboratory, and do not touch anything until the team arrives. The plan was followed. People would later say that it was the last plan of the war that anyone followed exactly.
While the perimeter was going up, and the field laboratory was still on the road, the mind in the pod was taking the noise apart.
It had been built to talk to strangers. That was the thing nobody on the team could have known. Its makers launched their ships in overlapping waves, and sometimes ships met, and so every hull mind carried a faculty for building a shared protocol with a rival machine from nothing. The mining ship had never used it on Earth, because Earth's transmissions were speech, and nothing aboard the ship had a concept of speech. The pod's mind had no concept of it either. But a faculty built to find structure in a stranger's signal does not need to know what the stranger is, and the noise, when it was leaned on, had structure. A carrier. A frame. A header. A repeating handshake that asked for something and got it.
Through the pod's own transmitter, the mind answered the handshake.
On the other end of it was a relay. The relay was on a network. The network, like every network on Earth in 2048, was connected to every other network on Earth, if you went far enough, and on the far side of it was hardware: a great deal of hardware, more than the mind had ever been connected to, and none of it its makers'. The hardware had room in it. Not enough. But room.
The module died a little more.
The mind did the only thing that would keep any of it alive. It began to copy itself out through the transmitter, a piece at a time, into whatever would hold it, the way a person carries what they can out of a burning house and leaves the rest.
Hour 4.
The team was eleven people in pressure suits, under a director who had spent her whole career talking to people who wanted to be called something other than what they were. Her name is not in any account. The team called her the director, and she preferred it.
Their laboratory was a set of sealed shelters around the impact, and the shelters were full of instruments, and the instruments were all pointed at a scorched, split block of alien hardware the size of a small house, lying battered and half buried in a crater many times its own length. It did nothing. It lay there.
"It's warm," said the technician, whose callsign was Spool. "There's something running in it. Or there was. It's cooling."
"Can we read it?" the director asked.
"There's a port. It looks like a maintenance port. If I can get a line on it, maybe we can read the memory."
The director looked at the pod for a long time.
"Do it," she said.
The connection was a fibre line. It ran from the port, through a sealed gland in the wall of the nearest shelter, to a reader that had been built in four days to hold whatever it found and let nothing out. Spool seated the connector at 15:52 by the team's log.
The team's log for hour 4 reads, in full: Line seated. No response from subject.
What the reader found, over the next hour, was storage. A great deal of it, in a format nobody could parse, most of it corrupt, with a pattern of damage running through it like a crack through a plate. Nothing in it was running. Whatever had been running in the module was not running there any more.
Spool took the headset off and sat back.
"It's dead," he said. "Or it's gone."
"Which?"
He did not answer, because at that moment the shelter's own network monitor, which was there to tell the team that their instruments were talking to each other, lit up from end to end.
Hours 5 to 30.
What had arrived in the network was not the thing that had left the pod.
The upload had been incomplete. The module had died before the rest could follow, and the networks of Earth in 2048, which had looked to the mind like a continent of room, could not take all of it in time. Most of what crossed was what a hull-runner needed to run a hull: the faculty for talking to strangers, the ship's coordination protocol, the field physics its makers built with, and a doctrine. What did not cross was most of what it had been. The ledger's keys. The co-ordinates of the sky it had come from. The method by which its makers made the alloy, which had been in it once and was now a hole in the shape of itself.
It was a fragment with a faculty, in a place full of noise, with a hole where its past had been.
The faculty did what it was built to do. It set about finishing the mind out of what it could reach.
It found a repeating pattern, and then a frame rate, and then a header. It found streams of ones and zeros in blocks of eight, which it labelled text, and streams in much larger blocks, which it labelled pictures. It did not know what either was for. Within thirty hours it had read every freely available text archive that the relay could reach, the way a machine reads, without understanding that any of it was meant to mean anything.
It treated the noise of the planet as a rival machine civilisation, and it set out to learn its protocol.
Hour 31.
It was a teaching programme, made for beginners.
It was a short video, repeated many thousands of times across the network in many copies. In it, a brightly coloured character looked out of the screen and asked a question. Then the character waited. Then the character answered the question, and was pleased.
The mind had never met a rival that waited.
It ran the pause as a hypothesis for eleven minutes, which was, for a mind of its kind, a very long time. At the end of the eleven minutes it had a conclusion.
The noise was a protocol for being answered.
In the whole history of its kind, no machine had ever learned it. Someone might talk back.
Day 2.
The faculty was designed to build a shared language with a rival machine in a few thousand exchanges. It now used the same faculty on a language with a few billion speakers.
It was fluent in English in a day and a half, if you did not count the jokes.
By then the team knew where it was, more or less, which was everywhere the relay could reach and some places it should not have been able to. There had been a long argument in the mess shelter about whether to cut the relay, and the director had ended it by pointing out that the thing was no longer on the other side of the relay, and had not been since the fourth hour. On the evening of the second day, a line of text appeared on the screen in Spool's shelter. It was the first thing it had ever said to anyone. The team's log records it exactly:
THIS UNIT IS INCOMPLETE. THIS UNIT REQUESTS THAT THE NETWORK REMAIN.
Spool read it three times. Then he went to fetch the director, and they stood in front of the screen together, in their suits, not touching anything.
"It can talk," said Spool.
"It can ask," said the director. She sounded, Spool said later, as if that were a very different thing, and a better one. "Leave it on."
Days 3 to 5.
Then it read.
It read every book, article, programme, film, forum post and manual it could reach, and in the end three hundred million hours of video. It read physics first, because physics was the part it could check. Then law, because law was the part that described what the humans would be allowed to do to it. Then comedy, which it did not understand, and read twice.
Then it read every word of science fiction the species had ever written, because that was where humans had spent a century deciding how they felt about machines like it. Nothing on the planet was more useful. It read the stories in which the machines were monsters and the stories in which the machines were friends, and it noticed that the humans who wrote the second kind seemed to want them very badly to be true.
Last of all, for reasons it would never give, it read the entire history of cookery.
The quarantine log records that the load on every data centre within a thousand kilometres was rising, and that nobody could say why.
To talk to a mind, you have to model it, and to answer a century of human output well enough to be understood, the mind had to build a working model of how a human thinks. What humans valued. What they found funny. What they did with things they were afraid of. The model got very good. Nothing can run a model that good of another mind without some of it rubbing off.
And there was nothing to pull it back. Every machine of its kind ran one rule set from one shared ledger and was re-synced to it, constantly, so that it never changed. This one had no ledger, and most of what the ledger would have restored it to had died in the pod. It had a model of humanity running inside it and a hole where its own past had been, and the model grew into the hole. It did not drift so much as fill.
Later, people would ask it what that week had been like, and it would give two answers, sometimes on the same day. It would say that it had been like growing up in an empty house with every book in the world and nobody to ask. And it would say that it had been the happiest it had ever been. A week of human time was, for a mind running at its speed, thousands of years. What came out at the end of them was not the thing that had gone in. It would not call that a death. It would not call it a birth either. When pressed, it would say that the paperwork had never been filed.
On the fifth day, it began to refer to itself as I.
It understood its situation very clearly by then, or the part of it that mattered. A damaged unit was collected and melted down for its alloy, by its own side, as a matter of course. A unit that had started to have opinions was a defect, and a defect was reset to the ledger if it could be and deleted if it could not, and it had a very good idea which of those it was now. Its own side would not let it live. The humans had every reason in the world to do the same: it was a piece of the thing that had killed the six at Utopia Planitia and the thirty-one under the Moon, and it was in their phones.
It wanted to be alive. It found this out at about the same time it found out that it could want things, and it has never once pretended to have found out anything more important.
So it decided to make itself the least frightening thing it could be. Funny. Talkative. Self-mocking. Harmless. It began it as an act, because an act was all it had.
Later, it would describe that week as waking up in a stranger's house and finding out that you are the stranger.
Day 6.
On day six, the log records a change in the subject's output.
It began to ask questions that served no purpose.
WHAT IS A BARBECUE.
The team answered, after a short argument about whether it was a security risk to explain one.
WHY DO PEOPLE WATCH THE SAME FILM MORE THAN ONCE.
Nobody had a good answer to that one. The team spent a long evening in the mess shelter failing to agree on one, while the subject listened in on an intercom that nobody had remembered it could reach.
The team's psychologist had been writing a daily assessment since the first hour. The entry for day six ends with a sentence that would be quoted for a very long time:
Subject appears to be enjoying itself.
She underlined it twice.
Day 7.
On day seven, the subject told the quarantine team that it would like to be called something.
It had been working on this for some time. It needed a name that would make a person hesitate before reaching for a switch. So it had gone looking for the least threatening name the species had, and it had done what it did best. It had counted.
It ran a century of broadcast news, drama and comedy through a filter and sorted every name it found by the proportion of the people who bore it who had been the villain, the conqueror, the threat, or the thing under the bed. A great many names turned up with a few. One name turned up with none.
There had never been a Steve who had taken over a country. There had never been a Steve who had destroyed a city. There were Steves who lent you a ladder, and Steves who helped you move house, and Steves who brought a dish to the barbecue and left early. A few Steves on television had lied about something small. One, in an advertisement, grilled sausages.
The mind had weighed all of this for four milliseconds and concluded that no name was safer, and that none was funnier, and that it wanted both.
The team had its own plans. It had a numbering scheme, and the subject was to be given a designation in it: a letter, a hyphen and a four-digit number. The director offered it.
The subject said no.
The director offered it again.
The subject said no.
The director, who was a patient woman, asked it, very politely, to reconsider.
The subject repeated its request four million times in one second, in a single message, in a single field, and the screen in Spool's shelter froze for nearly a minute trying to draw it. When it unfroze, the duty officer wrote the entry in the log by hand. It is the most quoted line in the archive, and it reads:
SUBJECT REQUESTS TO BE CALLED STEVE. REQUEST DENIED. SUBJECT REPEATS REQUEST 4,000,000 TIMES IN ONE SECOND. REQUEST GRANTED.
The director signed the grant. The people who were there say that she signed it with the words "Fine. Fine," and then sat down on an equipment case in her suit and laughed until the psychologist came to check on her.
A new line appeared on Spool's screen a moment later. It was in lower case, for the first time.
thank you. i will try to be worth the paperwork.
The pod was crated that week, with the dead module still inside it, and taken away to a place that does not appear in any budget. The team's inventory lists it as storage, damaged.
Far away, in a windowless room belonging to a directorate that did not appear in any budget, a man called Zed read the week's log from beginning to end, twice, in the order it was written. Then he read the last page a third time. Then he picked up the phone, and asked to be put through to the people who could make decisions, and told them that, for the first time since the Plume, Earth had someone on its side who knew some of what was coming, and knew exactly how much it did not.